---
milestone: v1.7
audited: 2026-04-05T00:00:00Z
status: gaps_found
scores:
  requirements: 49/55
  phases: 6/6
  integration: 49/55
  flows: 7/9
gaps:
  requirements:
    - id: "THEME-01"
      status: "unsatisfied"
      phase: "41"
      evidence: "ThemeSeedInput prop interface mismatch — ContentStudio passes wrong props"
    - id: "THEME-02"
      status: "partial"
      phase: "41"
      evidence: "Server renderer works but UI never displays palette (bundle undefined)"
    - id: "THEME-03"
      status: "unsatisfied"
      phase: "41"
      evidence: "themeJob.bundle does not exist on useContentJob — palette grid never renders"
    - id: "THEME-04"
      status: "unsatisfied"
      phase: "41"
      evidence: "ThemePreviewPanel never renders — gated on undefined bundle"
    - id: "THEME-05"
      status: "unsatisfied"
      phase: "41"
      evidence: "ThemeExportTabs never renders — gated on undefined bundle"
    - id: "THEME-06"
      status: "unsatisfied"
      phase: "41"
      evidence: "ThemeApplyConfirmDialog receives onOpenChange but expects onCancel prop"
    - id: "CONV-09"
      status: "unsatisfied"
      phase: "42"
      evidence: "convert.ts passes {} as StorageService — storage.putFile throws at runtime"
    - id: "SKILL-02"
      status: "partial"
      phase: "45"
      evidence: "All 9 SKILL.md files document wrong API path and 3 have wrong input field names"
  integration:
    - from: "Phase 41-05 ThemeSeedInput"
      to: "Phase 41-06 ContentStudio Themes tab"
      issue: "Incompatible prop interfaces from parallel worktree execution"
    - from: "Phase 42-03 convert route"
      to: "Phase 40 content-job-runner"
      issue: "StorageService passed as empty object — runtime crash on job completion"
    - from: "Phase 45 SKILL.md files"
      to: "Phase 40-42 routes and renderers"
      issue: "Wrong API path and input field names in skill documentation"
  flows:
    - name: "Themes tab"
      breaks_at: "ContentStudio.tsx — 3 prop mismatches + missing bundle state"
    - name: "Format conversion delivery"
      breaks_at: "convert.ts line 142 — StorageService is empty object"
tech_debt: []
nyquist:
  compliant_phases: 0
  partial_phases: 1
  missing_phases: 5
  overall: "partial"
---

# Milestone v1.7 — Content Generation Audit

## Summary

| Metric | Score |
|--------|-------|
| Requirements | 49/55 satisfied |
| Phases | 6/6 executed |
| Integration | 49/55 wired |
| E2E Flows | 7/9 complete |

## Unsatisfied Requirements

### THEME-01 through THEME-06 (Phase 41)
The theme engine server-side implementation is complete (palette generation, WCAG validation, exports, nexus-settings persistence). However, the ContentStudio Themes tab has 3 compile-time errors from worktree merge divergence:
1. `ThemeSeedInput` receives wrong props (`companyId/onSubmit/isLoading` vs `value/onChange/className`)
2. `themeJob.bundle` does not exist on `useContentJob` — palette display gated on undefined
3. `ThemeApplyConfirmDialog` receives `onOpenChange` but expects `onCancel`

### CONV-09 (Phase 42)
Convert route passes `{} as StorageService` to `contentJobRunner.dispatch`. Jobs start but crash on completion when `storage.putFile` is called.

### SKILL-02 (Phase 45) — Partial
All 9 SKILL.md files document `POST /api/content-jobs` but actual route is `POST /api/companies/:companyId/content-jobs`. Three files also have input field name mismatches.

## Working Flows (7/9)

| Flow | Status |
|------|--------|
| Diagrams | ✓ Complete |
| Icons | ✓ Complete |
| Wallpapers | ✓ Complete |
| Social Posts | ✓ Complete |
| Documents | ✓ Complete |
| Brand Kit | ✓ Complete |
| Presentations | ✓ Complete |
| Themes | ✗ Broken (UI compile errors) |
| Format Conversion | ✗ Broken (runtime crash on delivery) |

## Nyquist Compliance

| Phase | VALIDATION.md | Compliant |
|-------|---------------|-----------|
| 40 | exists | partial |
| 41 | exists | partial |
| 42 | missing | — |
| 43 | missing | — |
| 44 | missing | — |
| 45 | missing | — |