nexus/.planning/milestones/v1.3-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md

milestone	audited	status	scores	gaps	tech_debt	nyquist
v1.3	2026-04-02T02:45:00Z	tech_debt	requirements phases integration flows 63/63 6/6 47/50 9/12	requirements integration flows from to issue requirements server/src/routes/chat.ts server/src/services/pushService.ts sendPushToAll never called — push notifications infrastructure complete but no trigger fires PWA-06 from to issue requirements ui/src/components/MobileChatView.tsx ui/src/hooks/useOfflineQueue.ts Mobile handleSend has no offline guard — messages fail instead of queuing PWA-01 from to issue requirements ui/src/components/ChatPanel.tsx useStreamingChat Path 1 (new conversation) never calls startStream — first message gets no agent response CHAT-01 name breaks_at Push notification on agent response No call to sendPushToAll after streaming completes name breaks_at Offline message queue on mobile MobileChatView.handleSend bypasses useOfflineQueue name breaks_at New conversation streaming Path 1 handleSend sets activeConversationId but never calls startStream	phase items 23-brainstormer-flow human_needed: 2 must-haves need manual verification (brainstormer UX flows) phase items 24-search-history-branching gaps_found: 1/4 success criteria unverified (search does not index file attachment names) phase items 25-file-system human_needed: 8 items need browser testing (drag-drop, paste, voice, git log) phase items 26-pwa-performance vendor-react chunk empty due to Vite plugin-react JSX runtime interaction InstallPromptBanner only renders on desktop ChatPanel, not MobileChatView NotificationPermissionPrompt only renders on desktop ChatPanel, not MobileChatView	compliant_phases partial_phases missing_phases overall 21 22 23 26 24 25 partial

Milestone v1.3 — Audit Report

Audited: 2026-04-02 Status: tech_debt (all requirements checked, 3 integration gaps, accumulated debt)

Requirements Coverage

Score: 63/63 requirements checked in REQUIREMENTS.md

All requirement IDs across phases 21-26 are marked [x] complete.

Phase Verification Summary

Phase	Name	Status	Score
21	Chat Foundation	passed	13/13
22	Agent Streaming	passed	28/28
23	Brainstormer Flow	human_needed	13/15
24	Search, History & Branching	gaps_found	3/4
25	File System	human_needed	15/15
26	PWA & Performance	gaps_found	8/10

Cross-Phase Integration Issues

1. Push notifications never fire (PWA-06)

sendPushToAll in pushService.ts is defined but never called from any server-side event handler. The SSE streaming endpoint in chat.ts completes without dispatching push. Infrastructure is complete; trigger is missing.

2. Mobile offline queue not wired (PWA-01 partial)

MobileChatView.tsx does not use useOfflineQueue or useOnlineStatus. Its handleSend makes direct network calls with no offline guard. The OfflineBanner, InstallPromptBanner, and NotificationPermissionPrompt are also absent from the mobile layout.

3. New conversation streaming broken (CHAT-01 Path 1)

After creating a new conversation, ChatPanel and MobileChatView set activeConversationId but never call startStream. The first message in any new conversation gets no agent response until the user sends a second message.

Tech Debt Summary

Total: 8 items across 4 phases

• Phase 23: 2 human verification items pending
• Phase 24: Search does not index file attachment names
• Phase 25: 8 human verification items pending (drag-drop, paste, voice, git)
• Phase 26: vendor-react chunk empty, install/notification prompts missing on mobile

Nyquist Validation Coverage

Phase	VALIDATION.md	Compliant
21	exists	true
22	exists	true
23	exists	false (partial)
24	missing	—
25	missing	—
26	exists	false (partial)

Recommendation

All 63 requirements are formally checked. The 3 integration gaps are real wiring bugs but are each a 5-15 line fix. The tech debt is manageable. Milestone can proceed to completion with these items tracked.